13 Most Valuable Quarters Still in Circulation

April 25, 2025 by Jeffrey T. Poss

It’s easy to overlook loose change, especially quarters. But what if one of those coins jingling in your pocket was worth far more than 25 cents? While most circulating quarters are only worth face value, a handful stand out due to minting errors, rare varieties, or limited production runs. These valuable quarters are still occasionally found in circulation, making them a treasure trove for keen-eyed collectors and everyday folks alike. Here are 13 of the most valuable quarters you might still stumble upon today.

Table of Contents

1. 2004 Wisconsin Extra Leaf Quarters (High and Low Leaf)

One of the most famous modern quarter errors, the 2004 Wisconsin state quarter has two rare variants—one with an extra “high leaf” and another with a “low leaf” on the corn husk. These were accidental die variations during production and are highly collectible. Values for circulated versions typically start around $50–$100, with uncirculated specimens fetching up to $500 or more. Keep an eye out for this Wisconsin design—your next grocery store quarter could be a jackpot.

2. 1999 Delaware Spitting Horse Quarter

The first state quarter ever released, the 1999 Delaware quarter features Caesar Rodney on horseback. In the error version, a die crack near the horse’s mouth gives the appearance of it “spitting.” This unique visual error has made it a sought-after coin. While it won’t make you a millionaire, these quarters can sell for $10 to $50 depending on condition, and they still turn up in circulation from time to time.

3. 2005 Minnesota Extra Tree Quarter

Minnesota’s state quarter design features a tree-filled landscape—but on some coins, an extra tree appears due to die doubling. Known as the “Extra Tree” error, it comes in several varieties and has attracted serious collector attention. Depending on which version you have and its condition, it can fetch anywhere from $30 to over $100. It’s a good reason to take a second look at any 2005 quarter you find in your spare change.

4. 2000-P South Carolina Off-Center Quarter

Off-center strikes are one of the more obvious mint errors, and the 2000-P South Carolina quarter is occasionally found with this error. These misaligned coins can range from minor shifts to dramatic off-center appearances. The more dramatic the error, the higher the value—sometimes up to $300 or more. Even less severe examples can be worth $50 to $100.

5. 1999-P Connecticut Broadstrike Quarter

A broadstrike error occurs when a coin is struck outside the retaining collar, causing it to spread out unnaturally. The 1999-P Connecticut quarter is one such error that has gained notoriety. This quarter, with its famous Charter Oak design, looks slightly “melted” or oddly shaped. If found in good condition, these errors can command between $50 to $150, making them a true find for casual and seasoned collectors.

6. 1983-P Washington Quarter (No Mintmark)

The 1983-P quarter isn’t rare because of an error, but due to its scarcity in uncirculated condition. That year, few mint sets were made, and many quarters were heavily circulated. Finding one in excellent shape is challenging and can make it worth $20 to $100 or more, especially if it has strong luster and no wear. It’s one of those hidden gems that prove even older quarters can hold big value.

7. 1970-S Washington Quarter (Proof Overstruck on 1941 Canadian Quarter)

This extremely rare and bizarre error was discovered in a proof set. A 1970-S quarter was accidentally struck over a 1941 Canadian quarter, making it one of the most unusual error coins ever found. Though it’s unlikely you’ll find this one in change, it highlights the value potential of oddities. One sold for over $35,000—so it’s worth checking anything that looks even remotely strange.

8. 2001-P Vermont Doubled Die Quarter

Some Vermont quarters from 2001 show signs of doubling, particularly on the reverse where the trees and inscriptions can appear slightly blurred or overlapped. These are known as doubled die errors. Values vary by severity but generally fall in the $30 to $75 range. Since it’s a more subtle error, it often goes unnoticed, making it a perfect opportunity for a sharp-eyed collector.

9. 2009-D District of Columbia Quarter (Double Die Reverse)

This commemorative quarter features Duke Ellington at a piano, and some Denver-minted examples show doubling on the inscriptions. While not all doubled die errors are valuable, this one has captured the interest of collectors due to its unique design and limited mintage. These quarters can sell for $50–$100, especially in uncirculated condition.

10. 1982-D Washington Quarter (Small Date)

In 1982, due to cost-saving measures, the Mint reduced its production of uncirculated sets, resulting in fewer high-grade quarters. The 1982-D small date variety is particularly scarce in excellent condition, making it a high-demand collector’s item. Quarters from this year can be worth $10–$50 in circulated condition, with top-grade examples going for much more.

11. 1995 Doubled Die Obverse Quarter

Less well-known than the famous 1995 Lincoln Cent doubled die, this quarter variety also exhibits doubling on the obverse, especially around “IN GOD WE TRUST.” These are subtle and require magnification, but can be worth between $20 to $75 if found in good condition.

12. 2022-P Maya Angelou Quarter (Die Chip on Hand or Mouth)

Part of the American Women Quarters Program, the 2022 Maya Angelou design quickly gained attention when some quarters featured a die chip error—appearing as a blob on her hand or mouth. These are modern and common, but can still command $5–$25 if sold to the right buyer. As time passes, the value could grow, especially for pristine examples.

13. 2023-P Bessie Coleman Quarter (Cud Error on Airplane)

A more recent find, the Bessie Coleman quarter has appeared with a cud error—extra metal blobs formed from a broken die—on the airplane wing or helmet. These quarters are already drawing interest from modern error collectors and can sell for $10–$50 depending on condition and size of the cud. It’s an exciting reminder that valuable errors still come off the presses today.

FAQs

Q1: Are valuable quarters still really found in circulation today?

Yes! While rare, people regularly report finding valuable quarters in coin rolls, vending machines, and pocket change. It’s rare, but not impossible.

Q2: What’s the best way to check my quarters for value?

Use a magnifying glass, a good coin reference guide, and consider joining online coin communities or visiting a coin dealer for expert opinions.

Q3: Should I clean old quarters to increase their value?

Never clean your coins! Cleaning often lowers their value significantly. Collectors prefer coins in their original condition, even if they show wear.

Q4: Where’s the best place to sell a valuable quarter?

You can sell rare quarters through online platforms like eBay, coin shows, or to certified dealers. Be sure to get a professional appraisal first if the coin is highly valuable.

Conclusion

That quarter in your hand might be worth more than you think. Whether it’s a subtle die error, a unique minting mishap, or simply a low-mintage issue, these small coins can hold big value. With a sharp eye and a little knowledge, you could turn loose change into serious cash. So the next time you get a quarter, give it a closer look—you might just strike silver (or gold) in copper.